EXERCISE 12-17 (20 MINUTES)

3. As shown in part (1) above, the Electrical Division would insist on a

transfer price of at least $7.50 for the fitting. Would the Brake Division

make any money at this price? Again, the fixed costs are not relevant in

this decision since they would not be affected. Once this is realized, it is

evident that the Brake Division would be ahead by $6.00 per brake unit

if it accepts the $7.50 transfer price.

Selling price of the brake units ... $50.00

Less:

Purchased parts (from outside vendors) ... $22.50

Electrical fitting X52 (assumed transfer price) ... 7.50

Other variable costs ... 14.00 44.00

Brake Division contribution margin ... $ 6.00

In fact, since there is a positive contribution margin of $6, any transfer

price within the range of $7.50 to $13.50 (= $7.50 + $6.00) will improve

the profits of both divisions. So yes, the managers should be able to

agree on a transfer price.