EXERCISE 2-13 (15 MINUTES)

1. An analysis of the company’s quality cost report is presented below:

This Year Last Year

Amount Percent* Amount Percent*

Prevention costs:

Machine maintenance ... $ 120 2.5 20.3 $70 1.7 10.4

Training suppliers ... 10 0.2 1.7 0 0.0 0.0

Quality circles... 20 0.4 3.4 0 0.0 0.0

Total prevention costs ... 150 3.1 25.4 70 1.7 10.4

Appraisal costs:

Incoming inspection... 40 0.8 6.8 20 0.5 3.0

Final testing ... 90 1.9 15.3 80 1.9 11.9

Total appraisal costs... 130 2.7 22.0 100 2.4 14.9

Internal failure costs:

Rework ... 130 2.7 22.0 50 1.2 7.5

Scrap... 70 1.5 11.9 40 1.0 6.0

Total internal failure

costs... 200 4.2 33.9 90 2.1 13.4

External failure costs:

Warranty repairs... 30 0.6 5.1 90 2.1 13.4

Customer returns... 80 1.7 13.6 320 7.6 47.8

Total external failure

costs... 110 2.3 18.6 410 9.8 61.2

Total quality cost... $ 590 12.3 100.0 $670 16.0 100.0

Total production cost... $4,800 $4,200

* Percentage figures may not add down due to rounding.

Problem 2-22 (continued)

From the above analysis it would appear that Mercury, Inc.’s program has

been successful.

o Total quality costs have declined from 16.0% to 12.3% as a percent-

age of total production cost. In dollar amount, total quality costs

went from $670,000 last year to $590,000 this year.

o External failure costs, those costs signaling customer dissatisfaction,

have declined from 9.8% of total production costs to 2.3%. These

declines in warranty repairs and customer returns should result in in-

creased sales in the future.

o Appraisal costs have increased from 2.4% to 2.7% of total production

cost.

o Internal failure costs have increased from 2.1% to 4.2% of produc-

tion costs. This increase has probably resulted from the increase in

appraisal activities. Defective units are now being spotted more fre-

quently before they are shipped to customers.

o Prevention costs have increased from 1.7% of total production cost

to 3.1% and from 10.4% of total quality costs to 25.4%. The

$80,000 increase is more than offset by decreases in other quality

costs.